Publication details for Professor Thom BrooksBrooks, Thom (2008). Was Green a Utilitarian in Practice? Collingwood and British Idealism Studies 14(1): 5-15.
- Publication type: Journal Article
- ISSN/ISBN: 1744-9413
- Keywords: Green; Mill; crime; punishment
- Further publication details on publisher web site
Author(s) from Durham
Was Thomas Hill Green a Millian utilitarian in practice? Controversially, David Weinstein claims that he was. This paper examines the theories of crime and punishment held by Green and John Stuart Mill. I argue that this special focus raises new and significant practical differences between Green and Mill that have been overlooked by both Weinstein and his critics. I will argue that these differences between Green and Mill over crime and punishment give practical effect to their competing moral philosophies. If Green and Mill did indeed hold quite different positions on crime, punishment, and other fundamental matters of law, then we simply cannot say that Green was a Millian utilitarian in practice.