Natural disasters are creating oppressive governments
Natural disasters, such as tornados, cyclones and hurricanes, are causing governments to become more oppressive. This is according to research here at the School in partnership with Deakin Business School and Monash School of Business Malaysia.
Professor Nejat Anbarci, alongside Professor Mehmet Ulubasoglu and Dr Muhammad Habibur Rahman, reviewed data from 1950-2009 which measured every country’s polity score. This an international analysis tool which evaluates the strength of a country’s democratic system, from autocracy to democracy.
The changes in polity score both at the time of extreme weather conditions, and in the years afterwards, were reviewed. They found that after a substantial natural disaster, there was a rise in the autocracy of the affected country’s government.
In fact, the researchers found that storms deteriorate democratic conditions in island countries by 3.46% in the following year and 10.1% over the subsequent five years. Additionally, these governments increase their level of political oppression by around 2.5% per year following storm-related disasters.
Professor Anbarci said: “It’s likely that the disruption that severe storms cause to communities, including the breakdown of day-to-day business and routines, as well as the need for government intervention to support storm recovery, provide an opportunity for governments to tighten their control over citizens, taking advantage of a period of vulnerability. Citizens are less inclined to revolt against the tightening of these political regimes, as they become more accepting after a natural disaster of the fact that autocratic governments are much more efficient in decision-making during crises.”
The researchers found that it was small islands in particular that were impacted by this rise of autocracy, with landlocked countries and coastal countries not experiencing as much of an impact on their government system.
Dr Rahman said: “Storms often put our physical environment in peril, but its aftermath dampens democratic conditions in island countries. We observe that the incumbents in islands tend to secure their citizens’ support through providing post-disaster relief expenditure. Frequent storms offer more opportunities to the governments in allocating relief assistance that they generally do in exchange of restricting their citizens’ democratic rights; the ultimate outcome turns out to be authoritarian populism.”
Professor Ulubasoglu said: “The rise of authoritarian regimes in countries such as Haiti, Fiji and the Philippines are examples of countries where frequent severe storm events could have been a contributor to why these countries governments have remained autocratic over longer periods of time - these are countries we’re now dubbing ‘storm autocracies’. With climate change likely to cause more frequent natural disasters in these small islands, it is likely that we will see a greater decline in democracy in these countries.”
The researchers believe that climate change will only accelerate the likelihood and frequency of natural disasters, meaning their findings will become increasingly prevalent and impactful, in understanding the impact of climate change on the rise of autocratic governments.