Departmental Research Projects
Publication detailsCurtis, S.E., Copeland, A., Fagg, J., Congdon, P., Almog, M. & Fitzpatrick, J. The ecological relationship between deprivation, social isolation and rates of hospital admission for acute psychiatric care; a comparison of London and New York City. Health and Place. 2006;12:19-37.
- Publication type: Journal Article
- ISSN/ISBN: 1353-8292
- DOI: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2004.07.002
- Keywords: Psychiatric inpatient admissions, New York, London, Ecological analysis, Deprivation indices.
- Further publication details on publisher web site
- Durham Research Online (DRO) - may include full text
Author(s) from Durham
We report on comparative analyses of small area variation in rates of acute hospital admissions for psychiatric conditions in Greater London around the year 1998 and in New York City (NYC) in 2000. Based on a theoretical model of the factors likely to influence psychiatric admission rates, and using data from the most recent population censuses and other sources, we examine the association with area indicators designed to measure access to hospital beds, socio-economic deprivation, social fragmentation and ethnic/racial composition. We report results on admissions for men and women aged 15–64 for all psychiatric conditions (excluding self-harm), drug-related substance abuse/addiction, schizophrenia and affective disorders. The units of analysis in NYC were 165 five-digit Zip Code Areas and, in London, 760 electoral wards as defined in 1998. The analysis controls for age and sex composition and, as a proxy for access to care, spatial proximity to hospitals with psychiatric beds. Poisson regression modeling incorporating random effects was used to control for both overdispersion in the counts of admissions and for the effects of spatial autocorrelation. The results for NYC and London showed that local admission rates for all types of condition were positively and significantly associated with deprivation and the association is independent of demographic composition or ‘access’ to beds. In NYC, social fragmentation showed a significant association with admissions due to affective disorders and schizophrenia, and for drug dependency among females. Racial minority concentration was significantly and positively associated with admissions for schizophrenia. In London, social fragmentation was associated positively with admissions for men and women due to schizophrenia and affective disorders. The variable measuring racial/ethnic minority concentration for London wards showed a negative association with admission rates for drug dependency and for affective disorders. We discuss the interpretation of these results and the issues they raise in terms of the potential and limitations of international comparison.
Almog,M., Curtis,S.,Copela nd,A.,Congdon, P.,2004.
Geographical variation in acute psychiatric admissions
within New York City 1990–2000: growing inequalities in
service use? Social Science and Medicine,in press.
Becker,T., Knapp,M., Knudsen, H., Schene,A.,Tansella,M.,
Thornicroft,G.,Vazquez-Bar quero,J.,1999. The EPSILON
study of schizophrenia in five European countries—
design and methodology for standardising outcome measures
and comparing patterns of care and service costs.
British Journal of Psychiatry 175,514–521.
Besag,J.,York,J.,Mollie,A.,1991. Bayesian image restoration,
with two applications in spatial statistics (with
discussion). Annals of the Institute of Statistical Mathematics
Bhui,K., Bhugra,D.,2001. Transcultural psychiatry: some
social and epidemiological research issues. International
Journal of Social Psychiatry 47 (3),1–9.
Boardman,A., Hodgson,R.,Lewis,M.,Allen,K.,1997. Social
indicators and the prediction of psychiatric admission in
different diagnostic groups. British Journal of Psychiatry
Burr,J., 2002. Cultural stereotypes of women from South Asian
communities: mental health care professionals’ explanations
for patterns of suicide and depression. Social Science and
Medicine 55 (5),835–845.
Callan,A.,1996. Schizophrenia in Afro-Caribbean immigrants.
Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 89 (5),
Cameron,A.,Trivedi,P.,1990. Regression-based tests for over
dispersion in the poisson model. Journal of Econometrics 46
Carr-Hill,R., Hardman,G., Martin,S.,Peacock,S.,Sheldon,
T.,Smith, P.,1994. A Formula for Distributing NHS
Revenues Based on Small Area use of Hospital
Beds. University of York,Centre for Heath Economics,
Cliff,A.,Ord,J., 1981. Spatial Processes: Models and
Commission on Mental Health,2003. President’s New Freedom
Commission on Mental Health. New Freedom Commission
on Mental Health,Park Lawn Building,5600 Fischer’s
Lane,suite 13c-26. Rockeville, Maryland US.
Congdon,P., 1996a. The epidemiology of suicide in London.
Journal of Royal Statistical Society,Series A 159,515–533 .
Congdon,P., 1996b. General linear gravity models for the
impact of casualty unit closures. Urban Studies 33,
Congdon,P., 1997. Bayesian models for the spatial structure of
rare health outcomes: a study of suicide using the BUGS
program. Journal of Health and Place 3 (4),229–247.
Congdon,P.,2001. Bayesian models for suicide monitoring.
European Journal of Population 16,251–284.
Congdon,P., Smith, A.,Dean, C., 1998. Assessing psychiatric
morbidity from a community register: methods for Bayesian
adjustment. Urban Studies 35 (12),2323–2352.
Curtis,S.,Jones,I.R.,1998. Is there a place for Geography
geography in the analysis of health inequality? Sociology of
Health and Illness 20 (5 Special Issue),645–672 .
Dean, K.,James,H.,1981. Social factors and admission to
psychiatric hospital: schizophrenia in Plymouth. Transactions
of Institute of British Geographers NS 6,39–52.
Dear,M., Wolch,J., 1987. Landscapes of Despair: From
Institutionalization to Homelessness. Polity Press,Oxford.
Dekker,J.,Peen, J.,Goris, A.,Heijnen, H.,Kwakman ,H.,
1997. Social deprivation and psychiatric admission rates in
Amsterdam. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology
DETR,2000. Indices of Deprivation 2000. Regeneration
Research Summary,31. Department of Environment
Transport and the Regions,London.
DH,2003. Resource Allocation; Weighted Capitation. London,
Department of Health.
Diez-Roux,A., 1998. Bringing context back into epidemiology:
variables and fallacies in multilevel analysis. American
Journal of Public Health 88 (2),216–222.
Dixon,L.,Lyles,A., Smith,C., 2001. Use and costs of
ambulatory care services among Medicare enrollees with
schizophrenia. Psychiatric Services 52 (6),786–792.
Link,B.,Skodol, A.,Stueve, A.,1992. Socioeconomic
status and psychiatric disorders: the causation-selection
issue. Science NS 255,946–952 .
Driessen,G., Gunther, N.,Van Os,J., 1998. Shared social
environmentand psychiatric disorder: a multilevel analysis
of individual and ecological effects. Social Psychiatry and
Psychiatric Epidemiology 33 (12),606–612.
Duncan,C., Jones, K., Moon,G.,1996. Health-related
behaviour in context: a multilevel modelling approach.
Social Science and Medicine 42 (6),817–830.
Durkheim,E., 1963 (Original in 1897). Suicide: A Sociological
Study. Routledge and Kegan Paul,London.
Frank,R., Morlock,L., 1997. In: Richard,C.S. (Ed.),
Managing Fragmented Public Mental Health Services.
With an Introduction. Milbank Memorial Fund,
New York City.
Giggs,J., 1986. Schizophrenia and affective psychosis In
Nottingham. Social Sciene and Medicine 23,945–961 .
Giggs,J., 1988. The spatial ecology of mental illness. In: Smith,
C.J.,Giggs,J. (Eds.),Location And Stigma: Contemporary
Perspectives On Mental Health And Mental Health Care.
Unwin Hyman,London,pp. 103–133.
Glover,G.,Robin,E.,Emami,J.,et al., 1998. A needs index for
mental health care. Social Psychology and Psych Epidemiology
Goldberg, D.,Thornicro ft,G.,1998. Mental Health in our
Future Cities. Psychology Press,London.
Grob,G.,1994. Government and mental health policy—a
structural analysis. Milbank Quarterly 72 (3),471–500 .
Harrison,G., Glazebrook, C.,Brewin,J., Cantwell,R., Dalkin,
T.,Fox, R.,Jones,P.,Medley, I.,1997. Increased incidence
of psychotic disorders in migrants from the Caribbean to
the United Kingdom. Psychological Medicine 27 (4),
Harrison,J., Barrow, S., Creed,F., 1995. Social deprivation
and psychotic admission rates among different diagnostic
groups. British Journal of Psychiatry 167,456–462.
Harvey, C.,Pantelis, C.,Taylor,J.,et al.,1996. The Camden
Schizophrenia Study Surveys 2: High prevalence of schizophrenia
in an inner London borough and its relationship to
socio-demographic factors. British Journal of Psychiatry
Johnson,S., Ramsay, R.,Thornicroft,G., 1998. Londoner’s
mental health needs: the sociodemographic context. In:
Johnson,S., Ramsay, R.,Thornicroft,G., Brooks,L.,
Lelliott,P.,Peck, E.,Smith,H.,Chisholm, D.,Audini,B.,
Knapp,M.,Goldberg,D. (Eds.),London’s Mental
Health. Kings Fund Publishing,London,pp. 15–32
Jones,B.E.,Gray, M.A.,1986. Problems in diagnosing
schizophrenia and affective disorders among blacks. Hospital
and Community Psychiatry 37,61–65.
Jones,K.,Moon,G.,1993. Medical geography: taking space
seriously. Progress in Human Geography 17 (4),515–524.
Kearns, R.,Joseph,A.,1993. Space in its place: developing the
link in medical geography. Social Science and Medicine 37
Koppel,S.,McGuffin , P., 1999. Socio-economic factors that
predict psychiatric admissions at a local level. Psychological
Lamont, A.,Ukoumunn e,O.,Tyrer,P.,Thornicro ft,G.,
Slaughter,J.,2000. The geographical mobility of severely
mentally ill residents in London. Social Psychiatry and
Psychiatric Epidemiology 35 (4),164–169.
Lu,F., Du, N.,Gaw, A., Lin, K., 2002. A psychiatric residency
curriculum about Asian-American issues. Academic Psychiatry
Macintyre,S.,Maciver, S.,Soomans, A.,1993. Area,class and
health: should we be focusing in places or people. Journal of
Social Policy 22 (2),213–234.
Maylath,E.,Seidel,J.,Werner,B.,et al.,1999. Geographical
analysis of the risk of psychiatric hopsitalization in
Hamburg from 1988–1994. European Psychiatry 14 (8),
Maylath,E.,Seidel, J.,Schlattman n,P.,2000. Inequity in the
hospital care of patients with alcoholism and medication
addiction. European Addition Research 6 (2),79–83.
McAlpine,D.D., Mechanic, D., 2000. Utilization of specialty
mental health care among persons with severe mental
illness: the roles of demographics,need,insurance, and
risk. Health Services Research 35 (1),277–292 .
NHSCCC (National Health Service Clinical Coding Centre),
2000. Clinical Coding Guidance for Users of HES Data
(version 2). NHSCCC,London.
Schweitzer,L.,Kierszen baum,H.,1978. Community characteristics
that affect hospitalization and rehospitalization
rates in a municipal psychiatric hospital. Community
Mental Health Journal 14 (1),63–73.
Smith,C.,Hanham,R., 1981. Proximity and the formation of
public attitudes towards mental illness. Environment and
Planning A 13,147–165.
Smith,P.,Sheldon,T., Martin,S., 1996. An index of need for
psychiatric services based on in-patient utilisation. British
Journal of Psychiatry 169 (3),308–316 .
Snowden,L.,1999. African American service use for mental
health problems. Journal of Community Psychology 27 (3),
Spiegelhalter,D., Thomas, A.,Best, N.,2000. Winbugs
Manual: Version 1.3; http://www.mrc-bsu.cam.ac.uk/bugs.
Spiegelhalter,D.,Best,N.,Carlin,B.,van der Linde, A.,2002.
Bayesian measures of model complexity and fit. Journal of
the Royal Statistical Society. Series B 64 (3),583–639 .
Sun,D.,Tsutakawa, R.,Speckman,P.,1999. Posterior
distribution of hierarchical models using CAR(1) distributions.
Takahashi,L.,Gaber,S.,1998. Controversial facility siting in
the urban environment—resident and planner perceptions
in the United States. Environment and Behaviour 30 (2),
Tansella,M., Bisoffi, G., Thornicroft,G., 1993. Are social
deprivation and psychiatric service utilisation associated in
neurotic disorders? Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric
Thornicroft,G., 1991. Social deprivation and rates of treated
mental disorder: developing statistical models to predict
service utilisation. British Journal of Psychiatry 158,
Thornicroft,G.,Bisoffi,G.,De Salvia, D.,Tansella, M.,1993.
Urban–rural differences in the associations between social
deprivation and psychiatric services utiliation in schizophrenia
and all diagnoses; a case register study in Northern
Italy. Psychological Medicine 23,487–496.
Van Os,J., Castle, D.,Takei,N., Der,G.,Murray, R.,1996.
Psychotic illness in ethnic minorities; clarification from the
1991 census. Psychological Medicine 26 (1),203–208.
Wang,P.S.,Demler, O., et al.,2002. Adequacy of treatment for
serious mental illness in the United States. American
Journal of Public Health 92 (1),92–98.
Whitley,E., Gunnell,D.,Dorling,D.,Davey Smith,G.,1999.
Ecological study of social fragmentation,poverty,and
suicide. British Medical Journal 319 (7216),1034–1037.
WHO,1978. Manual of the International Statistical Classification
of Diseases,Injuries and Causes of Death, 9th Edition
revised. World Health Organization,Geneva.
WHO,1992. The International Statistical Classification of
Diseases and Related Health Problems,tenth revision.
World Health Organization,Geneva.