We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. You can change your cookie settings at any time. Otherwise, we'll assume you're OK to continue.

Durham University

Research & business

View Profile

Publication details for Dr Gordon MacLeod

Jones, M. & MacLeod, G. (2004). Regional spaces, spaces of regionalism: territory, insurgent politics and the English question. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 29(4): 433-452.

Author(s) from Durham


Amid the globalization of economic life and a myriad of powerful challenges to Westphalian traditions of political statehood, it is now routinely contended that regions are 'in resurgence'. Nonetheless, much of the debate on this purported regional renaissance is bedevilled by confusion over what scholars and activists mean by regions and an analogous mystification as to why some regions are 'successful', 'lagging' or 'different'. Our paper aims to instil some coherence to this debate by distinguishing between what we term regional spaces and spaces of regionalism. It then draws on this distinction to explore the institutionalization of England's South West region, highlighting some tensions which prevail over its economic future, its political representation, its territorial shape and cultural vernacular. In undertaking this, we demonstrate how the formation of any given regional map is reflective – and indeed constitutive – of an unevenly developing, often overlapping and superimposing mosaic of economic practices, political mobilizations, cultural performances and institutional accomplishments. This prompts us to question the currently fashionable inclination to fully jettison a scalar and/or territorial approach to the theory and practice of spatiality in favour of relational/topological/non-territorial approaches.


Adams J, Robinson P and Vigor A 2003 A new regional
policy for the United Kingdom IPPR, London
Agnew J 2000 From the political economy of regions to
regional political economy Progress in Human Geography
24 101–10
Jones M 2004 Social justice and the region: grass-roots
regional movements and the English question Space and
Polity 8 157–89
Jones M and MacLeod G 1999 Towards a regional renaissance?
Reconfiguring and rescaling England’s economic
governance Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers
24 295–313
Keating M 1998 The new regionalism in Western Europe: territorial
restructuring and political change Elgar, Aldershot
Keating M 2001 Nations against the state: the new politics of
nationalism in Quebec, Catalonia and Scotland Palgrave,
Labour Party 2001 Ambitions for Britain: Labour’s manifesto
2001 Labour Party, London
Lefebvre H 1976 The survival of capitalism: reproduction of
the relations of production Allison and Busby, London
Linehan D 2003 Regional surveys and the economic
geographies of Britain 1930–1939 Transactions of the
Institute of British Geographers 28 96–122
Lipietz A 2003 The national and the regional: their
autonomy vis-à-vis the capitalist world crisis in
Brenner N, Jessop B, Jones M and MacLeod G eds
State/space: a reader Blackwell, Oxford 239–55
London Assembly 2003 Local governance in London
Report of the Chair of the Business Management and
Appointments Committee 15 October
Loughlin J 2000 Regional autonomy and state paradigm
shift in Western Europe Regional and Federal Studies 10
Lovering J 1999 Theory led by policy: the inadequacies of
the ‘new regionalism’ illustrated from the case of Wales
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 23
MacLeod G 1998 Ideas, spaces and ‘Sovereigntyscapes’:
dramatizing Scotland’s production of a new institutional
fix Space and Polity 2 207–33
MacLeod G 2001 New regionalism reconsidered: globalization
and the remaking of political economic space International
Journal of Urban and Regional Research 25 804–29
MacLeod G and Jones M 2001 Renewing the geography
of regions Environment and Planning D: Society and Space
19 669–95
Marston S 2000 The social construction of scale Progress
in Human Geography 24 219–42
Massey D 1979 In what sense a regional problem?
Regional Studies 13 233–43
Massey D 1994 Space, place and gender Polity Press,
Massey D 1995 Spatial divisions of labour 2nd edn Macmillan,
Mebyon Kernow 1999 A fresh start for Cornwall: the manifesto
of Mebyon Kernow, the party for Cornwall Mebyon
Kernow, Cornwall
Mol A and Law J 1994 Regions, networks and fluids:
anaemia and social topology Social Studies of Science 24
Morgan K 2002 The English question: Regional perspectives
on a fractured nation Regional Studies 36 797–810
Musson S, Tickell A and John P 2003 A decentralized
state? Power, control and responsibility in English
devolution Paper presented at the annual conference of
the Association of American Geographers, New Orleans
NECC 1998 Briefing note North East Constitutional
Convention, Newcastle
O’Leary D 2000 Logos give identity to English tourism
Western Morning News 25 May 12
ODPM 2002 Strengthening regional accountability Consultation
paper Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, London
ODPM 2003 Your region, your say Office of the Deputy
Prime Minister, London
Paasi A 1986 The institutionalization of regions: a theoretical
framework for understanding the emergence of
regions and the constitution of regional identity Fennia
16 105–46
Paasi A 1996 Territories, boundaries and consciousness: the
changing geographies of the Finnish–Russian border John
Wiley, Chichester
Paasi A 2001 Europe as social process and discourse:
considerations of place, boundaries and identity
European Urban and Regional Studies 8 7–28
Paasi A 2002 Bounded space in the mobile world: deconstructing
‘regional identity’ Tijdschrift voor Economische
en Sociale Geografie 93 137–48
Paasi A 2003 Region and place: regional identity in question
Progress in Human Geography 27 475–85
Painter J 2002 Governmentality and regional economic
strategies in Hillier J and Rooksby E eds Habitus as a
sense of place Ashgate, Aldershot 115–39
Partridge S 1999 The British Union State: imperial hangover
or flexible citizens’ home Catalyst, London
Peate I C ed 1930 Studies in regional consciousness and
environment: essays presented to HJ Fleure Oxford University
Press, Oxford
Philo C and Parr H 2000 Institutional geographies: introductory
remarks Geoforum 31 513–21
Putnam R 1993 Making democracy work: civic traditions in
modern Italy Princeton University Press, Princeton
Regional Policy Commission 1996 Renewing the regions:
strategies for regional economic development. Report of the
Regional Policy Commission PAVIC Publications, Sheffield
Regional Studies 2002 Special issue: Devolution and the
English question Regional Studies 36 715–810
Richards S 1998 An evangelical DIY salesman Special
Supplement – Sowing the seeds of devolution New
Statesman 26 June 4–5
Sabel C 1989 Flexible specialization and the re-emergence
of regional economies in Hirst P and Zeitlin J eds
Reversing industrial decline? Industrial structure and policy
in Britain and her competitors Berg, Oxford 17–70
Sandford M 2002a The place for England in an asymmetrically
devolved UK Regional Studies 36 789–96
Sandford M 2002b The Cornish question: devolution in the
South-West region Report for the South West Constitutional
Convention and the Cornish Constitutional Convention
Constitution Unit, London
Sandford M and McQuail P 2001 Unexplored territory: elected
regional assemblies in England Constitution Unit, London
Scott A J 1998 Regions and the world economy: the coming
shape of global production, competition, and political order
Oxford University Press, Oxford
Scott A J ed 2002 Global city-regions: trends, theory, policy
Oxford University Press, Oxford
Smith A 2004 Regions, spaces of economic practice and
diverse economies in the ‘New Europe’ European Urban
and Regional Studies 11 9–25
Stobart J 2001 Regions, localities, and industrialisation:
evidence from the West Midlands circa 1780–1840
Environment and Planning A 33 1305–25
Storper M 1997 The regional world: territorial development in
a global economy Guilford Press, New York
SWCC 2002 The future: south west South West Constitutional
Convention, Bristol
SWRA 2002 Who owns the skills and learning agenda?
South West Regional Assembly Select Committee on Skills
and Learning South West Regional Assembly, Exeter
SWRDA 2000 Regional strategy for the south west of England
2000–2010 South West of England Regional Development
Agency, Exeter
Taylor P 1991 The English and their Englishness: a curiously
mysterious, elusive and little understood people
Scottish Geographical Magazine 107 146–61
Taylor P 1993 The meaning of the North: England’s ‘foreign
country’ within Political Geography 12 136–55
Thompson C 2000 Regional challenges to globalization:
perspectives from Southern Africa. New Political Economy
5 41–57
Thrift N 1996 Spatial formations Sage, London
Tomaney J 2000 End of the empire state? New Labour
and devolution in the United Kingdom International
Journal of Urban and Regional Research 24 675–88
Tomaney J 2001 Reshaping the English regions in Trench A
ed The state of the nations 2001: the second year of devolution
in the United Kingdom Imprint Academic, Exeter
Tomaney J and Mawson J eds 2002 England: the state of
the regions Policy Press, Bristol
Wessex Regionalists 1996 The statute of Wessex 3rd edn
Wessex Regionalists, Wokingham
Wessex Regionalists, Wessex Society and the Wessex
Constitutional Convention 2002 The case for Wessex: a
joint response to the White Paper on regional governance
Wessex Regionalists, Weston-super-Mare
Whetter J 1971 The Celtic background of Kernow MK
Publications, Padstow
Whitehead M 2003 In the shadow of hierarchy: metagovernance,
policy reform and urban regeneration in
the West Midlands Area 35 6–14.
Agnew J 2002 Place and politics in modern Italy University
of Chicago Press, Chicago
Allen J, Massey D and Cochrane A 1998 Rethinking the
region Routledge, London
Amin A 2002 Spatialities of globalization Environment and
Planning A 34 385–99
Amin A and Thrift N 1995 Globalisation, ‘institutional
thickness’ and the local economy in Healey P, Cameron S,
Davoudi S, Graham S and Madani-Pour A eds Managing
cities: the new urban context Wiley, Chichester 91–108
Amin A, Massey D and Thrift N 2003 Decentering the
nation: a radical approach to regional inequality Catalyst,
Banks J C 1971 Federal Britain: the case for regionalism
Harrap, London
Banks J C 1997 Regional development agencies Letter to S
Bradford Regional Policy Unit, Department of the Environment,
Secretary of the Wessex Regionalists, Cheltenham
BBC 2002 How devolution is changing our identity Report
on March 2002 Poll BBC, London
Bennett R J 1985 Regional movement in Britain: a review
of their aims and status Environment and Planning C:
Government and Policy 3 75–96
Benneworth P 2001 Regional development agencies: the early
years Regional Studies Association, Seaford
Bialasiewicz L 2002 Upper Silesia: rebirth of a regional
identity in Poland Regional and Federal Studies 12 111–32
Blair T 2000 Speech on Britishness The Labour Party,
Milbank, London
Brenner N, Jessop B, Jones M and MacLeod G 2003 State
space in question in Brenner N, Jessop B, Jones M and
MacLeod G eds State-space: a reader Blackwell, Oxford
Bridges 2002 The south west in Tomaney J and Mawson J
eds England: the state of the regions Policy Press, Bristol
Castells M 1996 The rise of the network society Blackwell,
Oxford 95–108
CFER 2000 The alternative view from Cornwall Democratic
Regions 1 6
Chen S and Wright T eds 2000 The English question
Fabian Society, London
Constitution Unit 1996 Regional government in England
Constitution Unit, London
Cooke P and Morgan K 1998 The associational economy: firms,
regions, and innovation Oxford University Press, Oxford
Cornish Constitutional Convention 2002 Devolution for
one and all: governance for Cornwall in the 21st century
Senedh Kernow, Truro
Cornish Constitutional Convention 2003 Your region,
your choice: the case for Cornwall. Cornwall’s response to
the government’s devolution White Paper Senedh Kernow,
Cox K 1998 Spaces of dependence, spaces of engagement
and the politics of scale, or: looking for local politics
Political Geography 17 1–23
Culture South West 2001 In search of chunky dunsters . . . a
cultural strategy for the South West Government Office
for the South West, Bristol
Darby H C 1948 The regional geography of Thomas
Hardy’s Wessex Geographical Review 38 426–43
Davies N 1999 The Isles: a history Macmillan, London
Deacon B ed 1999 The Cornish and the Council of Europe
framework for the protection of national minorities Joseph
Rowntree Reform Trust, York
Deacon B, Cole D and Tregidga G 2003 Mebyon Kernow
and Cornish nationalism Welsh Academic Press, Cardiff
DETR 1997 Building partnerships for prosperity: sustainable
growth, competitiveness and employment in the English
regions. Cm 3814 Stationery Office, London
DETR 2000 Regional government in England: a preliminary
review of literature and research findings Department of
Environment, Transport and the Regions, London
Devolve! 2003 Continuing commission on the south:
proposal Devolve!, Leicester
DTLR 2002 Your region, your choice: revitalising the English
regions. Cm 5511 The Stationery Office, London
Fawcett C B 1919 Provinces of England: a study of some
geographical aspects of devolution Williams and Norgate,
Fleet J 1983 Cornwall as a region Paper presented to
the Conference on Cornish identity: a living bequest,
organized by Cowethas Flamank, Perranporth, May
George A 2003 A view from the bottom-left hand corner
Patten Press, Penzance
Harvie C 1994 The rise of regional Europe Routledge, London
Hazell R 2003 The state of the nations 2003: the third year of
devolution in the United Kingdom Imprint Academic, Exeter
Hirst P 1997 From statism to pluralism: democracy, civil society
and global politics UCL Press, London
Hogwood B W 1996 Mapping the regions: boundaries, coordination
and government Policy Press, Bristol
Holston J 1995 Spaces of insurgent citizenship Planning
Theory 13 35–51
Hudson R 2002 ‘Problem regions’ and the ‘regional
problem’: changes in geographical thought and practice
Paper presented at the annual conference of the Association
of American Geographers, Los Angeles, March
Jeffery C 2001 Devolution: a radical experiment? Social
Sciences: News from the Economic and Social Research
Council 49 5
John P and Whitehead A 1997 The renaissance of English
regionalism in the 1990s Policy and Politics 25 7–17
John P, Musson S and Tickell A 2002 England’s problem
region: regionalism in the South East Regional Studies 36
Jones M 2001 The rise of the regional state in economic
governance: ‘partnerships for prosperity’ or new scales
of state power? Environment and Planning A 33 1185–211