Publication details for Dr Gordon MacLeodMacLeod, G. (2001). New regionalism reconsidered: Globalization and the remaking of political economic space. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 25(4): 804-829.
- Publication type: Journal Article
- ISSN/ISBN: 0309-1317, 1468-2427
- DOI: 10.1111/1468-2427.00345
- Keywords: Uneven development, Social regulation, Learning region, Industrial districts, Development agencies, Urban governance, Local governance, State, Fordism, Europe.
- Further publication details on publisher web site
- Durham Research Online (DRO) - may include full text
Author(s) from Durham
Amid the near frenzied exaltation of economic globalization and a purported decline of the nation state, a range of subnational regional economies and urban metropoles are increasingly being canonized as the paradigmatic exemplars of wealth creation. Indeed, across many of the advanced developed countries a whole host of academics, consultants, influential commentators, politicians and bourgeois interest groups are readily invoking the region to be the appropriate site for regulating global capitalism. In a recent article in IJURR, though, John Lovering disputes this emerging New Regionalism, viewing it to be seriously compromised by several practical and theoretical inadequacies. This article has two principal aims. First, and while sympathetic to the general tenor of Lovering's critique, it offers a rejoinder through some sobering reflections on what might be recovered from the range of New Regionalist perspectives currently vying for attention within critical studies of regional development. Second, it presents a series of future theoretical directions for a geopolitically sensitive regional research agenda, drawing on recent thinking from the new regional geography, globalization and the politics of scale, institutional-relational state theory and the regulation approach. An argument is made that a synthesis of these perspectives might intensify our understanding of the social and political construction of regions, the uneven geography of growth, and the moments of re-scaled regionalized state power that now enframe the process of economic governance.
Aglietta, M. (1979) A theory of capitalist regulation: the US
experience. Verso, London.
Allen, J., D. Massey and A. Cochrane (1998) Rethinking the region.
Allmendinger, P. and M. Tewdwr-Jones (2000) Spatial dimensions and
of planning and the ‘new regionalism’. Environment and Planning C:
Government and Policy
Amin, A. (1999) An institutionalist perspective on regional economic
Journal of Urban and Regional Research 23, 365–78.
—— and S. Graham (1999) Cities of connection and disconnection. In J.
Allen, D. Massey and M.
Pryke (eds), Unsettling cities, Routledge, London.
—— and N. Thrift (1994) Living in the global. In A. Amin and N.
institutions, and regional development in Europe, Oxford University
—— and —— (2001) Cities: rethinking urban theory. Polity,
Anderson, J. (1996) The shifting stage of politics: new medieval and
Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 14, 133–53.
Beccatini, G. (1990) The Marshallian industrial district as a
socio-economic notion. In F. Pyke and
W. Sengenberger (eds.), Industrial districts and inter-firm co-operation
in Italy, International
Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva.
Beck, U. and E. Beck-Gernshiem (1996) Individualization and ‘precarious
and controversies of a subject-oriented sociology. In P. Heelas, S. Lash
and P. Morris (eds.),
Detraditionalization, Blackwell, Oxford.
Bertramsen, R. (1991) From the capitalist state to the political economy.
In R. Bertramsen, J.
Frolund and J. Torfing (eds.), State, economy and society, Unwin Hyman,
Boyer, R. (1990) The regulation school: a critical introduction. Columbia
University Press, New
—— and J. Hollingsworth (1997) From national embeddedness to spatial
nestedness. In R. Boyer and J. Hollingsworth (eds.), Contemporary
embeddedness of institutions, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Brenner, N. (1997) Global, fragmented, hierarchical: Henri Lefebvre’s
geographies of globalization.
Public Culture 10, 135–67.
—— (1999) Globalisation as reterritorialisation: the re-scaling of
urban governance in the
European Union. Urban Studies 36, 431–51.
—— (2000) The urban question as a scale question: reflections on
Lefebvre, urban theory
and the politics of scale. International Journal of Urban and Regional
Research 24, 361–78.
—— (2001) Urban governance and the production of new state spaces:
reflections on state
restructuring in western Europe. Mimeograph.
Brusco, S. (1990) The idea of the industrial district: its genesis. In F.
Pyke and W. Sengenberger
(eds.), Industrial districts and inter-firm co-operation in Italy,
International Institute for Labour
Callon, M., J. Law and A. Rip (eds.) (1986) Mapping the dynamics of
science and technology.
Cameron, A. and R. Palan (1999) The imagined economy: mapping
transformations in the
contemporary state. Millennium 28, 267–88.
Castells, M. (1996) The rise of the network society. Blackwell, Oxford.
Cerny, P. (1999) Globalization and the erosion of democracy. European
Journal of Political
Research 36, 1–26.
Cooke, P. (1995) Keeping to the high road: learning, reflexivity and
associative governance in
regional economic development. In P. Cooke (ed.), The rise of the
rustbelt, UCL Press, London.
—— (1997) Regions in a global market: the experiences of Wales and
Review of International Political Economy 4, 349–81.
—— and K. Morgan (1998) The associational economy: firms, regions and
University Press, Oxford.
Cox, K. (1993) The local and the global in the new urban politics: a
critical view. Environment and
Planning D: Society and Space 11, 433–48.
Cox, R. (1993) Structural issues of global governance: implications for
Europe. In S. Gill (ed.),
Gramsci, historical materialism, and international relations, Cambridge
Deas, I. and K. Ward (2000) From the ‘new localism’ to the ‘new
regionalism’? The implications
of regional development agencies for city-regional relations. Political
Geography 19, 273–92.
Dicken, P. (1994) The Roepke Lecture in economic geography: global-local
tensions: firms and
states in the global space economy. Economic Geography 70, 101–19.
DiGiovanna, S. (1996) Industrial districts and regional economic
development: a regulation
approach. Regional Studies 30, 373–86.
Duncan, S. and S. Goodwin (1988) The local state and uneven development.
Esser, J. and J. Hirsch (1989) The crisis of fordism and the dimensions
a ‘postfordist’ urban and
regional structure. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
Florida, R. (1995a) Toward the learning region. Futures 27, 527–36.
——(1995b) The industrial transformation of the Great Lakes region. In
P. Cooke (ed.), The rise of
the rustbelt, UCL Press, London.
—— (1996) Regional creative destruction: production organization,
globalization, and the
economic transformation of the Midwest. Economic Geography 72, 314–34.
Gamble, A. (1994) The free economy and the strong state: the politics of
Gereffi, G. (1996) The illusive last lap in the quest for
developed-country status. In J. Mittelman
(ed.), Globalization: critical reflections, Lynne Rienner, London.
Gertler, M. (1995) Round table: discussion of regional advantage: culture
and competition in
Silicon Valley and Route 128 by AnnaLee Saxenian. Economic Geography 70,
—— (1997) The invention of regional culture. In R. Lee and J. Wills
(eds.), Geographies of
economies, Arnold, London.
Giddens, A. (1984) The constitution of society: outline of a theory of
—— (1998) The third way: the renewal of social democracy. Polity,
Gilbert, A. (1988) The new regional geography in English and
French-speaking countries. Progress
in Human Geography 12, 208–28.
Glasmeier, A. (1994) Flexible districts, flexible regions? The
institutional and cultural limits to
districts in an era of globalization and technological paradigm shifts.
A. Amin and N. Thrift
(eds.), Globalization, institutions, and regional development in Europe,
Grabher, G. (1993) The weakness of strong ties: the lock-in of regional
development in the Ruhr
area. In G. Grabher (ed.), The embedded firm: on the socioeconomics of
Gramsci, A. (1971) Selections from the prison notebooks. Lawrence and
Granovetter, M. (1985) Economic action and social structure: the problem
American Journal of Sociology 91, 481–510.
Harding, A. (1994) Urban regimes and growth machines: towards a
cross-national research agenda.
Urban Affairs Quarterly 29, 356–82.
——, R. Evans, M. Parkinson and P. Garside (1996) Regional government
in Britain: an economic
solution? Policy Press, Bristol.
——, S. Wilks-Heeg and M. Hutchins (1999) Regional Development
regionalism: the question of accountability. Environment and Planning C:
Policy 17, 669–83.
Harrison, B. (1994) Lean and mean: the changing landscape of corporate
power in the age of
flexibility. Basic Books, New York.
Harvey, D. (1989) From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: the
transformation of urban
governance in late capitalism. Geografiska Annaler 71B, 3–17.
Harvie, C. (1994) The rise of regional Europe. Routledge, London.
Hirst, P. (1997) From statism to pluralism: democracy, civil society and
global politics. UCL Press,
—— and J. Zeitlin (eds.) (1989) Reversing industrial decline? Berg,
Hudson, R. (1994) Institutional change, cultural transformation, and
economic regeneration: myths
and realities from Europe’s old industrial areas. In A. Amin and N.
Thrift (eds.), Globalization,
institutions, and regional development in Europe, Oxford University
—— (1999) What makes economically successful regions in Europe
successful? Implications for
transferring success from west to east. RGS-IBG Economic Geography
Working Paper no. 99/01 (http://www.egrg.org.uk).
—— and A. Williams (1995) Divided Britain. 2nd edn., Wiley,
——, M. Dunford, D. Hamilton and R. Kotter (1997) Developing regional
strategies for economic
success: lessons from Europe’s economically successful regions.
Urban and Regional
Studies 4, 365–73.
Jenson, J. (1990) Representations in crisis: the roots of Canada’s
permeable Fordism. Canadian
Journal of Political Science 23, 653–83.
Jessop, B. (1977) Recent theories of the capitalist state. Cambridge
Journal of Economics 1, 353–
—— (1989) Neo-conservative regimes and the transition to
In M. Gottdiener and N.
Komninos (eds.), Capitalist development and crisis theory: accumulation,
spatial restructuring, Macmillan, London.
—— (1990) State theory: putting capitalist states in their place.
—— (1994) Post-Fordism and the state. In A Amin (ed.), Post-Fordism:
—— (1997a) A neo-Gramscian approach to the regulation of urban
strategies, hegemonic projects, and governance. In M. Lauria (ed.),
theory: regulating urban politics in a global economy, Sage, London.
—— (1997b) Twenty years of the (Parisian) regulation approach: the
paradox of success and
failure at home and abroad. New Political Economy 2, 503–26.
—— (1998) Cities as the new national champions in international
competition: the remaking and
re-aligning of entrepreneurial cities in the articulation of city, state
and region in the global
order. Paper presented at the RC21 International Sociological Association
State and Region in a Global Order: Towards the 21st Century, Hiroshima
—— (1999) Reflections on globalization and its (il)logics. In P.
Dicken, P. Kelley, K. Olds and H.
Yeung (eds.), Globalization and the Asia Pacific: contested territories,
—— (2000) The crisis of the national spatio-temporal fix and the
tendential ecological dominance
of globalizing capitalism. International Journal of Urban and Regional
Research 24, 322–60.
Jonas, A. and D. Wilson (eds.) (1999) The urban growth machine: critical
decades later. SUNY, New York.
Jones, M. (1997) Spatial selectivity of the state? The regulationist
enigma and local struggles over
economic governance. Environment and Planning A 29, 831–64.
—— (1999) New institutional spaces: TECs and the remaking of economic
—— (2001) The rise of the regional state in economic governance:
‘partnerships for prosperity’ or
new scales of state power? Environment and Planning A 33, 1185–211.
—— and G. MacLeod (1999) Towards a regional renaissance?
England’s economic governance. Transactions of the Institute of British
Geographers 24, 295–
Keating, M. (1997) The invention of regions: political restructuring and
territorial government in
western Europe. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 15,
—— (1998) The new regionalism in western Europe: territorial
restructuring and political
change. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.
—— and J. Loughlin (eds.) (1998) The political economy of
Frank Cass, London.
Keil, R. (1998) Globalization makes states: perspectives of local
governance in the age of the world
city. Review of International Political Economy 5, 616–46.
Kelly, P. (1999) The geographies and politics of globalization. Progress
in Human Geography 23,
Kofman, E. (1995) Citizenship for some but not for others: spaces of
citizenship in contemporary
Europe. Political Geography 14, 121–37.
Kra¨tke, S. (1999) A regulationist approach to regional studies.
Environment and Planning A 31,
Krugman, P. (1997) Pop internationalism. MIT Press, Cambridge MA.
Lagendijk, A. (2000) Will the New Regionalism survive? Tracing dominant
concepts in economic
geography. Mimeograph, CURDS, University of Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, UK
—— and J. Cornford (2000) Regional institutions and knowledge:
tracking new forms of regional
development policy. Geoforum 31, 209–18.
Lauria, M. (ed.) (1997) Reconstructing urban regime theory: regulating
urban politics in a global
economy. London, Sage.
Leadbeater, C. (2000) Living on thin air: the new economy (with a
blueprint for the 21st century).
Le Gale`s, P. (1998a) Government and governance of regions: structural
weaknesses and new
mobilizations. In P. Le Gale`s and C. Lequesne (eds.), Regions in Europe,
—— (1998b) Regulations and governance in European cities.
International Journal of Urban and
Regional Research 22, 482–506.
—— and C. Lequesne (eds.) (1998) Regions in Europe. Routledge,
Leitner, H. (1990) Cities in pursuit of economic growth: the local state
as entrepreneur. Political
Geography Quarterly 9, 146–70.
Leyshon, A. and A. Tickell (1994) Money order? The discursive
of Bretton Woods
and the making and breaking of regulatory space. Environment and Planning
A 26 1861–90.
Lipietz, A. (1994) The national and the regional: their autonomy
vis-a`-vis the capitalist world
crisis. In R. Palan and B. Gills (eds.), Transending the state-global
divide: a neo-structuralist
agenda in international relations, Lynne Reinner Publishers, London.
Lovering, J. (1990) Fordism’s unknown successor: a comment on Scott’s
theory of flexible
accumulation and the re-emergence of regional economies. International
Journal of Urban and
Regional Research 14, 159–74.
—— (1995) Creating discourses rather than jobs: the crisis in the
cities and the transition fantasies
of intellectuals and policy makers. In P. Healey, S. Cameron, S. Davoudi,
S. Graham and A.
Madanipour (eds.), Managing cities: the new urban context, John Wiley,
—— (1998) Globalization, unemployment and ‘social exclusion’ in
Europe: three perspectives on
the current policy debate. International Planning Studies 3, 35–56.
—— (1999) Theory led by policy: the inadequacies of the ‘new
regionalism’ (illustrated from the
case of Wales). International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 23,
MacKinnon, D. (2000) Managerialism, governmentality and the state: a
to local economic governance. Political Geography 19, 293–314.
——, A. Cumbers and K. Chapman (2001) Learning, innovation and
critical appraisal of current debates in regional development studies.
Progress in Human
Geography 25.4 (forthcoming).
MacLeod, G. (1997) Globalizing Parisian thought-waves: recent advances in
the study of social
regulation, politics, discourse and space. Progress in Human Geography
—— (1999a) Institutions, regulation, and ‘new state spaces’:
reflections on the new regionalism
Conference ‘Regional Potentials in an Integrating Europe’, University
of the Basque Country,
—— (1999b) Place, politics and ‘scale dependence’: exploring the
structuration of Euroregionalism.
European Urban and Regional Studies 6, 231–53.
—— (2000) The learning region in an age of austerity: capitalizing on
entrepreneurialism, and reflexive capitalism. Geoforum 31, 219–32.
—— (2001) Beyond soft institutionalism: accumulation, regulation,
their geographical fixes.
Environment and Planning A 33, 1145–67.
—— and M. Goodwin (1999) Space, scale and state strategy: rethinking
urban and regional
governance. Progress in Human Geography 23, 503–27.
—— and M. Jones (2001) Renewing the geography of regions. Environment
and Planning D:
Society and Space 19.6 (forthcoming).
Malmberg, A. and P. Maskell (1999) Guest editorial: localized learning
development. European Urban and Regional Studies 6, 5–8.
Mann, M. (1984) The autonomous power of the state. European Journal of
Sociology 25, 185–213.
Markusen, A. (1996) Sticky places in slippery space: a typology of
industrial districts. Economic
Geography 72, 293–313.
—— (1999) Fuzzy concepts, scanty evidence, policy distance: the case
for rigour and policy
relevance in critical regional studies. Regional Studies 33, 869–84.
——, P. Hall and A. Glasmeier (1986) High tech America: the what, how,
where and why of the
sunrise industries. Allen and Unwin, Boston.
Martin, R. and P. Sunley (1997) The post-Keynesian state and the space
economy. In R. Lee and J.
Wills (eds.), Geographies of economies, Arnold, London.
Massey, D. (1979) In what sense a regional problem? Regional Studies 13,
——, J. Allen and P. Sarre (eds.) (1999) Human geography today.
Mayer, M. (1994) Post-Fordist city politics. In A. Amin (ed.),
Post-Fordism: a reader, Blackwell,
McDowell, L. (1997) Capital culture: gender at work in the city.
Mitchell, D. (1997) The annihilation of space by law: the roots and
implications of anti-homeless
laws in the United States. Antipode 29, 303–35.
Mittelman, J. (1996) Rethinking the ‘New Regionalism’ in the context
of globalization. Global
Governance 2, 190–92.
Morgan, K. (1997) The learning region: institutions, innovation and
regional renewal. Regional
Studies 31, 491–503.
—— (1999) England’s unstable equilibrium: the challenge of the
Planning C: Government and Policy 17, 663–7.
Moulaert, F. (1996) Rediscovering spatial inequality in Europe: building
blocks for an appropriate
‘regulationist’ analytical framework. Environment and Planning D:
Society and Space 14, 155–
—— and E. Swyngedouw (1989) A regulation approach to the geography of
systems. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 7, 327–45.
Mulkay, M. (1979) Science and the sociology of knowledge. Allen and
Murray, R. (1992) Europe and the new regionalism. In M. Dunford and G.
Kafkalas (eds.), Cities
and regions in the New Europe, Belhaven, London.
New Statesman (1998) Special Supplement: New Regionalism. 26 June.
Ohmae, K. (1995) The end of the nation state. Harper Collins, London.
Paasi, A. (1996) Regions as social and cultural constructs: reflections
debates. In M. Idvall and A. Salomonsson (eds.), Att Skapa en Region om
territorium, NordREFO, Copenhagen.
Painter, J. and M. Goodwin (1995) Local governance and concrete research:
uneven development of regulation. Economy and Society 24, 334–56.
Panitch, L. (1994) Globalisation and the state. Socialist Register.
Parsons, W. (1988) The political economy of British regional policy.
Peck, J. (2000) Doing regulation. In G. Clark, M. Gertler and M. Feldman
(eds.), A handbook of
economic geography, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
—— and A. Tickell (1992) Local modes of social regulation? Regulation
theory, Thatcherism and
uneven development. Geoforum 23, 347–63.
—— and —— (1994) Searching for a new institutional fix: the
after-Fordist crisis and global-local
disorder. In A. Amin (ed.), Post-Fordism: a reader, Blackwell, Oxford.
——and——(1995) The social regulation of uneven development:
‘regulatory deficit’, England’s
South East, and the collapse of Thatcherism. Environment and Planning A
Pinch, S. and N. Henry (1999) Discursive aspects of technological
innovation: the case of the
British motor-sport industry. Environment and Planning A 31, 665–82.
Piore, M. and C. Sabel (1984) The second industrial divide: possibilities
for prosperity. Basic
Books, New York.
Polanyi, K. (1944) The great transformation: the political and economic
origins of our time.
Beacon Press, Boston.
—— (1957) [1992 edn.] The economy as instituted process. In M.
Granovetter and R. Swedberg
(eds.), The sociology of economic life, Westview Press, Boulder, CO.
Porter, M. (1990) The competitive advantage of nations. Macmillan,
Poulantzas, N. (1978) State, power, socialism. New Left Books, London.
Pudup, M.B. (2000) Review of ‘Rethinking the region’. Annals of the
Association of American
Geographers 90.2, 404–6.
Putnam, R., with R. Leonardi and R. Nanetti (1993) Making democracy work:
civic traditions in
modern Italy. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Sabel, C. (1989) Flexible specialisation and the re-emergence of regional
economies. In P. Hirst
and J. Zeitlin (eds.), Reversing industrial decline?, Berg, Oxford.
—— (1993) ‘Studied trust’: building new forms of cooperation in a
volatile economy. Human
Relations 46, 1133–70.
—— and J. Zeitlin (1997) Stories, strategies, structures: rethinking
historical alternatives to mass
production. In C. Sabel and J. Zeitlin (eds.), Worlds of possibilities:
flexibility and mass
production in western industrialization, Cambridge University Press,
Sassen, S. (2000) Digital networks and the state. Theory, Culture &
Society 17, 19–33.
Saxenian, A-L. (1994) Regional advantage: culture and competition in
Silicon Valley and Route
128. Harvard University Press, Boston
Sayer, A. (2000) Realism and social science. Sage, London.
Schoenberger, E. (1999) The firm in the region and the region in the
In T. Barnes and M.
Gertler (eds.), The new industrial geography: regions, regulation and
Scott, A.J. (1988a) Flexible production systems and regional development:
the rise of new
industrial spaces in North America and western Europe. International
Journal of Urban and
Regional Research 12, 171–85.
—— (1988b) Metropolis: from the division of labor to urban form.
University of California, Los
—— (1996) Regional motors of the global economy. Futures 28,
—— (1998) Regions and the world economy: the coming shape of global
and political order. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
—— (1999) The cultural economy: geography and the creative field.
Media, Culture and Society
—— (2000) The cultural economy of Paris. International Journal of
Urban and Regional
Research 24, 567–82.
Smith, N. (1988) The region is dead! Long live the region! Political
Geography Quarterly 7, 141–
—— (1992) Geography, difference and the politics of scale. In J.
Doherty, E. Graham and M.
Malek (eds.), Postmodernism and the social sciences, St Martin’s Press,
—— (1998) Giuliani time: the revanchist 1990s. Social Text 57,
—— (2000) What happened to class? Environment and Planning A 32,
Soja, E. (1996) Thirdspace: journeys to Los Angeles and other
—— (2000) Postmetropolis: critical studies of cities and regions.
Stenning, A. (2001) ‘Solidarity’, and the challenges of
transformation: restructuring labor and
community in post-socialist Poland. Paper presented at the Annual
Association of American
Geographers Conference, New York, 21 February–3 March.
Storper, M. (1995) The resurgence of regional economies, ten years later:
the region as a nexus of
untraded interdependencies. European Urban and Regional Studies 2,
—— (1997) The regional world: territorial development in a global
economy. Guilford, New
—— and A.J. Scott (1989) The geographical foundations and social
regulation of flexible
production complexes. In J. Wolch and M. Dear (eds.), The power of
—— and R. Salais (1997) Worlds of production: the action frameworks
the economy. Harvard
University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Swyngedouw, E. (1997) Neither global nor local: ‘glocalization’ and
the politics of scale. In K.
Cox (ed.), Spaces of globalization: reasserting the power of the local,
Guilford, New York.
—— (2000) Authoritarian governance, power, and the politics of
rescaling. Environment and
Planning D: Society and Space 18, 63–76.
Thompson, C. (2000) Regional challenges to globalization: perspectives
from Southern Africa.
New Political Economy 5, 41–57.
Thomson, J. (1991) A strategic-relational account of economic state
interventions. In R.
Bertramsen, J. Frolund and J. Torfing (eds.), State, economy and society,
Thrift, N. (1996) Spatial formations. Sage, London.
Tickell, A. and J. Peck (1992) Accumulation, regulation, and the
geographies of post-Fordism:
missing links in regulationist research. Progress in Human Geography 16,
To¨mmel, I. (1997) The EU and the regions: towards a three-tier system
a new mode of
regulation? Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 15,
Urry, J. (1981) The anatomy of capitalist societies. Macmillan, London.
Weiss, L. (1997) Globalization and the myth of the powerless state. New
Left Review 225, 3–27.
Willis, E. (1998) The writer’s voice: intellectual work in the culture
of austerity. In S. Aronowitz
and J. Cutler (eds.), Post-work: the wages of cybernation, Routledge, New
Wills, J. (1999) Political economy I: Global crisis, learning and labour.
Progress in Human
Geography 23, 443–51.
Yeung, H.W.C. (1998) Capital, state and space: contesting the borderless
Institute of British Geographers 23, 291–309.
—— (2000) The dynamics of Asian business systems in a globalising
Review of International
Political Economy 7, 399–433.