Cookies

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. You can change your cookie settings at any time. Otherwise, we'll assume you're OK to continue.

Durham University

Research & business

View Profile

Publication details for Professor Marcus Power

Sidaway, J.D. & Power, M. (2005). 'The tears of Portugal': empire, identity, 'race', and destiny in Portuguese geopolitical narratives. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 23(4): 527-554.

Author(s) from Durham

Abstract

Geopolitical discourses are constitutive moments within the expression and construction of ‘national’ identities. Approaching geopolitics and identities as contested and fluid domains, we examine the relationships between geopolitical narratives and visions of Portugueseness (Portugalidade). The focus is on the frames of geopolitical thought developed in 20th-century Portugal, with particular reference to the post-1945 period and with some consideration of the transformations since 1974 accompanying the collapse of what was both the first and the most enduring European overseas empire. This study of Portuguese geopolitical discourses leads to a conclusion in which we reflect on the significance of relations between the ‘colonial’ and the ‘postcolonial’ and the articulations of East –West and North – South in geopolitical discourses. This permits wider critique concerning the location of geopolitics within 20th-century and contemporary imperialisms.

References

Agnew J, 2003 Geopolitics: Re-visioningWorld Politics (Routledge, London)
Agnew J, Mitchell K, Toal G, 2002, ``Introduction'', in A Companion to Political Geography
Eds J Agnew, KMitchell, G Toal (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 1 ^ 9
Atkinson D, 1995, ``Geopolitics, cartography and geographical knowledge: envisioning Africa
from Fascist Italy'', in Geographical Knowledge and Imperial Power 1820 ^ 1940 Eds M Bell,
R A Butler, M J Heffernan (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 290 ^ 332
BaerW, Leite A P N, 1992, ``The peripheral economy, its performance in isolation and with
integration: the case of Portugal'' Luso-Brazillian Review 24(2) 1 ^ 35
Bahia dos Santos F, 1955 Polit|¨ ca Ultramarina de Portugal Sociedade de Geografia de Lisboa,
Rua das Portas de Santa Anta¬ o 1000, Lisboa 1100
Barkawi T, LaffeyM, 2002, ``Retrieving the imperial: empire and international relations''Millennium:
Journal of International Studies 31(1) 109 ^ 127
Basset T, 1994, ``Cartography and empire-building in nineteenth-centuryWest-Africa'' Geographical
Review 84 316 ^ 335
Blanco J, 1995, ``Bibliography: selected bibliography in English and some key works in Portuguese'',
in ACentenary Pessoa Ed. E Lisboa, with L C Taylor (Carcanet Press, Manchester) pp 315 ^ 335
Bloom H, 1995 TheWestern Canon (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
Borges-Coelho J P, 2002, ``African troops in the Portuguese Colonial Army, 1961 ^ 1974: Angola,
Guinea-Bissau and Mozambique'' Portuguese Studies Review 10(1) 129 ^ 150
Bruce N, 1975 Portugal: The Last Empire (David and Charles, North Pomfret,VT)
Buck-Morss S, 2000 Dreamworld and Catastrophe: The Passing of Mass Utopia in East and West
(MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
Cabral A, 1973 Return to the Source: Selected Speeches (Monthly Review Press, New York)
Caetano M, 1973 Razo¬ es da Presenc° a de Portugal no Ultramar (Secretariado de Propaganda
Nacional, Lisbon)
Campbell D, 1992 Writing Security (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
Carvalho M M, 1997, ``O ensino da historia e `ideologia' imperial'' Histo¨ ria 34 19
Chassin L M, 1961, ``Geopolitica e a marinha do futoro'' Revista Marinha do Futoro 455 27 ^ 40
Clarence-SmithG, 1985 TheThird Portuguese Empire, 1825 ^ 1975: AStudy in Economic Imperialism
(Manchester University Press, Manchester)
Comprido J B, 1956, ``Importaª ncia geopol|¨ tica de Portugal para a estrate¨ gia do mundo livre''
Anais do Club Militar Naval 86(7^ 9) 223 ^ 268
Coombes A E, 1994 Reinventing Africa. Museums, Material Culture and Popular Imagination in
Late Victorian and Edwardian England (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
Costa-Pinto A, 1992 O Salazarismo e o Facismo Europeu: Problemas de Interpretac° a¬ o nas Ciencias
Socias (Editorial Stampa, Lisbon)
Crespo M P, 1956, ``Portugal na pol|¨ tica e na estrate¨ gia mundias''Anais do Club Militar Naval
96(4 ^ 6) 135 ^ 166, 275 ^ 298
Crollen L, 1973 Portugal, the US and Nato (Leuven University Press, Leuven)
da Costa Santa R J G, 1944, ``A geopolitica e as colo¨ nias de Angola e Moc° ambique''Anua¨ rio da
Escola Superior Colonial 23/24 133 ^ 140
Dalby S, 1994, ``Gender and critical geopolitics: reading security discourse in the new world
disorder'' Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 12 595 ^ 612
da Silva A R, 1964 Pol|¨ tica Ultramarina Portuguesa, Seus Objectivos Histo¨ ricos e Actuais, Sua
Posic° a¬ o Perante a Conjuntura Internacional Conference held at Instituto des Altos Estudos
Militares, 28 February 1964 (Ageª ncia Geral do Ultramar, Lisbon)
de AndradeAA,1961ManyRaces ^ OneNation:RacialNon-discriminationAlways the Cornerstone
of Portugal's Overseas Policy copy available from Sidaway and Power
de Carvalho J B, 1974 Rumo do Portugal: A Europa ou o Atlaª ntico (Livros Horizonte, Lisbon)
de Figueiredo A, 1975 Portugal: FiftyYears of Dictatorship (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth,Middx)
deMedeiros P, 2002, ``War pics: photographic representations of the ColonialWar'' Luso-Brazilian
Review 39(2) 91 ^ 103
de Sousa Santos B, 1993, ``O Estado, as relac° oes salariais e o bem-estar social na semiperiferia:
o caso portugueª s'', in Portugal: Um Retrato Singular Ed. de Sousa Santos (Afrontamento,
Porto) pp 33 ^ 69
de Sousa Santos M I R, 1992, ``An imperialism of poets: the modernism of Fernando Pessoa and
Hart Crane'' Luso-Brazillian Review 24(1) 84 ^ 95
de Sp|¨ nola A, 1974 Portugal e o Futuro: Ana¨ lise da Conjuntura Nacional (Arca¨ dia, Lisbon)
Dodds K J, 1993, ``Geopolitics, cartography and the state in Latin America'' Political Geography
12 361 ^ 381
Dodds K, Atkinson D (Eds), 2000 Geopolitical Traditions: A Century of Geopolitical Thought
(Routledge, London)
Feldman-Bianco B, 2001, ``Colonialism as a continuing project: the Portuguese experience''
Identities 8 477 ^ 482
Fernandes J M, 2003 Portugueª s Suave: Arquitecturas do Estado Novo (Instituto Portugueª s do
Patrimo¨ nio Arquitecto¨ nico, Lisbon)
Ferreira J J B, 1992, ``Portugal `as portas do se¨ culo XXI: ensaio geopolitico e geostrate¨ gico''
Revista Militar 44(4) 243 ^ 268
FerreiraV M, 1987, ``Uma nova ordem urbana para a capital do impe¨ rioöa `modernidade' da
urbanizac° a¬ o e o `autoritarismo' do Plano Director de Lisboa, 1938 ^ 1948'', in O Estado Novo
das Origens ao Fim da Autarcia 1926 ^ 1959 Ed. F Rosas (Editorial Presenc° a, Lisbon)
pp 359 ^ 375
Freyre G, 1961 Portuguese Integration in the Tropics (Agencia Geral do Ultramar, Lisbon)
Galva¬o H, 1936 O Impe¨ rio (Edico¬ es SPN, Lisbon)
Galva¬ oH,1976 AMinha Luta Contra o Salazarismo e o Communismo emPortugal (Arca¨ dia, Lisbon)
Gilroy P, 1993 The Black Atlantic, Modernity and Double Consciousness (Verso, London)
Gilroy P, 2000 Between Camps: Nations, Cultures and the Allure of Race (Penguin Books,
Harmondsworth, Middx)
Graham L S,Wheeler DL, 1983 In Search ofModern Portugal:The Revolution and its Consequences
(Wisconsin University Press, Madison,WI)
Gregory D, 1994 Geographical Imaginations (Blackwell, Oxford)
Gristwood A, 1999, ``Commemorating empire in twentieth-century Seville'', in Imperial Cities:
Landscape, Display and Identity Eds F Driver, D Gilbert (Manchester University Press,
Manchester) pp 155 ^ 173
Guimara¬ es A, 1987, ``O labirinto dos mitos'', in O Estado Novo das origens ao Fim da Autarcia
1926 ^ 1959 volume 2, Eds A C Pinto et al (Fragmentos, Lisbon) pp 107 ^ 121
Gunn G C, 1999 Timor Loro Sae 500 Years (Livros do Oriente, Macau)
Hall S, 1996, ``When was the postcolonial? Thinking at the limit'', in The Postcolonial Question:
Common Skies, Divided Horizons Eds I Chambers, L Curti (Routledge, London) pp 242 ^ 260
Hamilton C Y, 2000 Cuisines of Portuguese Encounters (Hippocrene, New York)
Hanlon J, 1986 Beggar your Neighbours (James Currey, London)
Hepple LW, 1986, ``Geopolitics, generals and the state in Brazil'' Political Geography Quarterly
5 579 ^ 596
Hepple LW, 1992, ``Metaphor, geopolitical discourse and the military in Latin America'', in
WritingWorlds: Discourse, Text and Metaphor in the Representation of Landscape
Eds T J Barnes, J S Duncan (Routledge, London) pp 136 ^ 154
Ingram A, 2001, ``Alexander Dugin: geopolitics and neo-fascism in post-Soviet Russia'' Political
Geography 20 1029 ^ 1051
Ju¨ nior A D, 1969 Portugal e o Occidente (Instituto de Angola, Luanda)
Kearns G, 2003, ``Imperial geopolitics: geopolitical visions at the dawn of the American century'',
in A Companion to Political Geography Eds J Agnew, K Mitchell, G Toal (Blackwell, Oxford)
pp 173 ^ 186
Kelly P, 1984 Checkerboards and Shatterbelts: The Geopolitics of South America (University of
Texas Press, Austin, TX)
Kennan G (Mr X), 1947, ``The sources of soviet conduct'' Foreign Affairs July, 566 ^ 582
Lourenc° o E, 1978 O Labrinto da Saudade, Psicana¨ lise M|¨ tica do Destino Portugueª s (Dom Quixote,
Lisbon)
Madureira L, 1995, ``The discreet seductiveness of the crumbling empireösex, violence and
colonialism in the fiction of Anto¨ nio Lobo Antunes'' Luso-Brazillian Review 32(1) 17 ^ 29
Maltez J A, 2002 Curso de Relac° oes Internacionais (Pricipa, Estorial)
Medina J, 1999, ``The old lie: some Portuguese contemporary novels on the Colonial Wars in
Africa (1961 ^ 1974)'' Portuguese Studies Review 15 149 ^ 161
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 1970 Portugal Replies to the United Nations (Imprensa Nacional, Lisbon)
MinterW, 1972 Portuguese Africa and theWest (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
Mitchell T, 1988 Colonizing Egypt (University of Califonia Press, Berkeley, CA)
Mondlane E, 1969 The Struggle for Mozambique (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
NatterW, 2003, ``Geopolitics in Germany, 1919 ^ 45'', in A Companion to Political Geography
Eds J Agnew, K Mitchell, G Toal (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 187 ^ 203
Neto J P, 1963, ``O significado do multirracialismo Portugue¨ s'' Separata da Revista Ultramar
numbers 13 ^ 14
Newitt M, 1981 Portugal in Africa, The Last Hundred Years (Hurst, London)
Nowell C E, 1982 The Rose-colored Map: Portugal's Attempt to Build an African Empire from the
Atlantic to the Indian Ocean (Junta de Investigac° o¬ es Cient|¨ fica do Ultramar, Lisbon)
Oliveira PA, 2000,``Apol|¨ tica externa doMarcelismo: a questa¬ o Africana'', in Diplomacia e Guerra:
Pol|¨ ca de Defesa em Portugal do Final da Monarquia ao Marcelismo Ed. F Martins (Edico¬ es
Colibry, Eè vora) pp 233 ^ 265
Ornelas J N, 2001, ``The construction of identity in Portuguese contemporary narrative'', in Global
Impact of the Portuguese Language Ed. A R de Laguna (Transaction, New Brunswick, NJ)
pp 145 ^ 165
Oè Tuathail G, Agnew J, 1992, ``Geopolitics and discourse: practical geopolitical reasoning and
US foreign policy'' Political Geography 11 190 ^ 204
Parker G, 1985 Western Geopolitical Thought in the Twentieth Century (Croom Helm, London)
Pinto J E R, 1956, ``Importaª ncia geopolitica de Portugal para a estrate¨ gia do Mundo Livre''
Anais do Club Militar Naval 86(10 ^ 12) 401 ^ 426
Power M, 2000, ``Aqui Lourenc° o Marques!! Radio-colonization and cultural identity in colonial
Mozambique 1932 ^ 1974'' Journal of Historical Geography 26 605 ^ 628
Power M, 2001, ``Geo-politics and the representation of Portugal's African wars: examining the
limits of the `Vietnam syndrome' '' Political Geography 20 461 ^ 491
Prior G, 1951, ``A geopolitica e a estrate¨ gia mundial''Anais de Marinha 11(16) 3 ^ 15
Quintanilha F E G (Ed.), 1971Fernando Pessoa, Sixty Portuguese Poems (University ofWales Press,
Cardiff )
Raby D L, 1988 Fascism and Resistance in Portugal (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
Reichmann R (Ed.), 1999 Race in Contemporary Brazil: From Indifference to Inequality (Pennsylvania
State University Press, University Park, PA)
Ribeiro M C, 2002, ``Empire, colonial wars and post-colonialism in the contemporary Portuguese
imagination'' Portuguese Studies Review 18 132 ^ 214
Robertson D, 1990, ``The vision of colony and metropolis in Portuguese Colonial War literature'',
in Literature and War Ed. D Bevan (Rodopi, Amsterdam) pp 119 ^ 140
Robinson R A H, 1979 Contemporary Portugal: A History (Allen and Unwin, London)
Rosas F (Ed.), 1992 Nova Histo¨ ria de Portugal e o Estado Novo (Editorial Presenc° a, Lisbon)
Roucek J S, 1964, ``Portugal in geopolitics'' Contemporary Review 205 476 ^ 488
Rozenberg G, 2003, ``Windswept outpost for war summit'' The Times 15 March, page 16
Ryan M, 1994 War and Peace in Ireland: Britain and the IRA in the NewWorld Order (Pluto Press,
London)
Said E, 1994 Culture and Imperialism (Vintage Books, New York)
Salazar O, 1960a, ``Panorama da pol|¨ tica mundial'', in Discursos e Notas Politicas,Volume 6,
1959 ^ 1966 (Coimbra Editora, Coimbra) pp 3 ^ 48
Salazar O, 1960b, ``Portugal e a campanha anticolonista. Discurso pronunciada na sessa¬ o da
Assembleia Nacional de 30/11/60'', in Discursos e Notas Politicas,Volume 6, 1959 ^ 1966
(Coimbra Editora, Coimbra)
Salazar O, 1961, ``O Ultramar Portugueª s e o ONU. Discurso pronunciada na sessa¬ o extraordina¨ ria
da Assembleia Nacional em 30/6/1961'', in Discursos e Notas Pol|¨ ticas,Volume 6, 1959 ^ 1966
(Coimbra Editora, Coimbra) pp 127 ^ 158
Salazar O, 1962, ``Defesa de Angolaödefesa da Europa. Discurso proferido na Cova da Moura
em 4/12/62'', in Discursos e Notas Ooliticas,Volume 6, 1959 ^ 1966 (Coimbra Editora, Coimbra)
pp 59 ^ 66, 227 ^ 237
Sanches M C, 1963, ``Medita¨ c° o¬ es geopoliticas ^ geostrate¨ gicas''Anais do Clube Militar Naval 93
1 ^ 3, 10 ^ 12; 94 1 ^ 3
Sapega E W, 2002, ``Image and counter-image: the place of Salazarist images of national identity
in contemporary Portuguese visual culture'' Luso-Brazilian Review 39(2) 45 ^ 64
Saraiva M, 1990, ``O error colonialista'' Boletim da Sociedade de Geografia de Lisboa series
108(1 ^ 6) 91 ^ 103
Serra¬ o J, 1976, ``Repensar Portugal'' Nac° a¬ o e Defesa April
Sharp J, 1993, ``Publishing American identity: popular geopolitics, myth and the Readers Digest''
Political Geography 12 491 ^ 503
Sharp J, 1998, ``Reel geographies of the NewWorld Order: patriotism, masculinity and geopolitics
in post Cold War American movies'', in Rethinking Geopolitics Eds G Oè Tuathail, S Dalby
(Routledge, London) pp 152 ^ 169
Sidaway J D, 1992, ``Mozambique: destabilization, state, society and space'' Political Geography
Quarterly 11 239 ^ 258
Sidaway J D, 1999, ``America and the Portuguese Empire'', in The American Century: Consensus
and Coercion in the Projection of American Power Eds D Slater, P J Taylor (Blackwell, Oxford)
pp 195 ^ 209
Sidaway J D, 2000, ``Iberian geopolitics'', in Geopolitical Traditions: A Century of Geopolitical
Thought Eds K Dodds, D Atkinson (Routledge, London) pp 118 ^ 149
Sidaway J D, 2001, ``Rebuilding bridges: a critical geopolitics of Iberian transfrontier cooperation
in a European context'' Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 19 743 ^ 778
Sidaway J D, Simon D, 1993, ``Geopolitical transition and state formation: the changing political
geographies of Angola, Mozambique and Namibia'' Journal of Southern African Studies
19(1) 6 ^ 28
Sieber, R T, 2001, ``Remembering Vasco da Gama: contested histories and the cultural politics
of contemporary nation-building in Lisbon, Portugal'' Identities 8 549 ^ 581
Smith N, 2000, ``Is a critical geopolitics possible? Foucault, class and the vision thing'' Political
Geography 19 365 ^ 371
Taylor P J, 1990 Britain and the Cold War: 1945 as Geopolitical Transition (Pinter, London)
Taylor P J, 1993, ``Geopolitical world orders'', in Political Geography of the Twentieth Century:
A Global Analysis Ed. P J Taylor (Belhaven Press, London) pp 31 ^ 61
Teixeira N S, 1992, ``From neutrality to alignment: Portugal in the foundation of the Atlantic Pact''
Luso-Brazilian Review 29(2) 113 ^ 126
Tsfahuenhy M, 1998, ``Mobility, racism and geopolitics'' Political Geography 17 499 ^ 515
Ventura A, 1994, ``Resisteª ncias ao regime ditatorial: Henrique Galva¬ o'', in Histo¨ ria de Portugal:
DosTempos Pre¨ -histo¨ ricos aosNossosDias,Volume XXIII,OEstadoNovo Opressa¬ o e Resisteª ncia
Ed. J Medina (Ediclube, Lisbon) pp 235 ^ 238
Weber C, 1994, ``Shoring up a sea of signs: how the Caribbean Basin Initiative framed the US
invasion of Grenada'' Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 12 547 ^ 558
Wheeler D, 1993 ^ 94, ``Do estado novo ao estado velho'' Portuguese Studies Review 3(1) 106 ^ 112
Young R, 1990 White Mythologies:Writing History and theWest (Routledge, London)