Crowd Sourcing and Worship (The Church and the Avant-garde #2)
(4 October 2011)
I've been following Imogen Heap's progress on her new album - the first song - working title #heapsong1, now Lifeline - began with a call to fans to send in ideas for lyrics and sound samples...
I've been following Imogen Heap's progress on her new album - the first song - working title #heapsong1, now Lifeline - began with a call to fans to send in ideas for lyrics and sound samples. The final song is part Imogen Heap, part Imogen Heap fans. Heap was also involved in the Love the Earth Film which was edited from thousands of nature clips sent in by the public. This collaborative concept is called crowd-sourcing, and developed as a creative business solution, involving potentially anyone, primarily online. Sometimes, contributors are rewarded, but crowd-sourcing has come in for criticism if it is seen to exploit folks who offer free service. In practice, because it is an opt-in process, this is not a problem, and I'm pretty sure that if Imogen Heap used my lyric idea, I'd be happy enough to leave it at that.
Such collaborative creativity is not new - a Cathedral is nothing if not a collaborative work of art. Furthermore, during worship, there is a sense in which the minister's role is to focus and join together the work of the wholepeople - an opt-in moment of creative communal expression. Whether or not it feels like this is, of course, a different matter, and on that note, the possibilities of online crowd sourcing present themselves as an exciting framework for worship. It suggests to me ways in which diverse and marginal voices can gather into some kind of shared expression, deepening the scope of artistic expression in ways that are perhaps simply not otherwise practical.
Does the minister then become an 'editor'? Perhaps, and perhaps again such crowd-sourcing opens up ways of reducing the amount of final control. These are tricky issues, but they are worth facing if the potential gain is a renewal of communal worship that draws on as wide and diverse a range of expression as the people are diverse. It suggests a way in which the Christian worship might embrace the gift of the avant-garde.
Spiritual Disciplines: The Holy Habit of Acting. @longingtobeholy
No, not that sort of acting. I’m not suggesting we should all be treading the boards. Action. Doing stuff. Because I read Nehemiah and I see an awful lot being […]
#BIGRead14: Contemplation (Read by @ajstarkordish)
I have kept myself still before you. the flood of ideas is stemmed. The carnival of images has passed. The fragments of music quietened. Words have come, chosen and repeated; […]
(19 Apr 2014) » #BIGRead14: Contemplation (Read by @ajstarkordish)
Hearing God’s Word (Nehemiah 8) (Ed Mackenzie)
How do we engage with Scripture, on-line and off-line? How do we allow it to shape and saturate our lives, our workplaces and our homes, our families and our friendships? […]
(18 Apr 2014) » Hearing God’s Word (Nehemiah 8) (Ed Mackenzie)
#BIGRead14: Mysterious Cross (Read by @RevMartinPoole)
Unfamiliar cross, I know your shape, your form. your meaning has been my study year on year. yet I know you not. Symbol of reconciliation, of love, of grace. Why […]
(18 Apr 2014) » #BIGRead14: Mysterious Cross (Read by @RevMartinPoole)
Is an Online Church Really a Church? A Grumpy Response to Ed Stetzer (@tim_hutchings)
This month, Ed Stetzer tackled the thorny question of online churches for Christianity Today magazine. Is an online church really a church? Well, Ed’s answer is mostly no. Every church should […]