Cookies

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. You can change your cookie settings at any time. Otherwise, we'll assume you're OK to continue.

Institute of Advanced Study

IAS Staff

Publication details for Professor Stuart Elden

Elden, S. (2005). Missing the point: globalization, deterritorialization and the space of the world. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 30(1): 8-19.

Author(s) from Durham

Abstract

This article provides a critique of a dominant strand of the literature on globalization – that which suggests it can be understood as deterritorialization. It argues that suggestions that we have moved away from territorial understandings of politics fail to conceptually elaborate the notion of territory itself. Drawing parallels between mathematics and politics in the seventeenth century, the paper claims that the notion of territory is dependent on a particular way of grasping space as calculable. This way of understanding space makes bounded territories possible, but also underlies new global configurations. In other words globalization is a reconfiguration of existing understandings rather than the radical break some suggest. The article concludes by making some comments on this reconfiguration, and suggesting that further historical and conceptual work on territory is necessary before it can be thought to be superseded.

References

Agnew
J
1995 The territorial trap: the geographical assumptions of international relations theory in Agnew J and Corbridge S eds Mastering space: hegemony, territory and international political economy Routledge, London 78–100 Agnew J
1999 Mapping political power beyond state
boundaries: territory, identity and movement in world politics Millennium
28 499–521
Akerman
J R
1995 The structuring of political territory in early printed atlases Imago Mundi
47 138–54
Akkerman
A
2001 Urban planning in the founding of
Cartesian thought
Philosophy and Geography
4 141–67
Albert
M
1999 On boundaries, territory and postmodernity:
an international relations perspective in Newman D ed Boundaries, territory and postmodernity Frank Cass, London 53–68 Amin A
1997 Placing globalisation
Theory, Culture and
Society
14 123–37
Amin
A
2002 Spatialities of globalisation
Environment and
Planning A
34 385–99
Amin
A and Thrift
N
1997 Globalisation, socio-economics,
territoriality in
Lee R and Wills J eds Geographies of
economies Arnold, London 147–57
Anderson J 1996 The shifting stage of politics: new medieval and postmodern territorialities? Environment and Planning D: Society and Space
14 133–53 Appadurai A 1996 Modernity at large: cultural dimensions of globalisation University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis Aristotle 1936 Physics Clarendon Press, Oxford. 1996 Translation by Robin Waterfield Oxford University Press, Oxford Badie B 2000 The imported state: the westernization of the political order translated by Claudia Royal Stanford University Press, Stanford Braubach M 1948 Der Wastfälische Friede Aschendorffsche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Münster Brenner N 1999a Beyond state-centrism? Space, territoriality, and geographical scale in globalization studies Theory and Society 28 39–78 Brenner N 1999b Globalisation as reterritorialization: the re-scaling of urban governance in the European Union Urban Studies 36 431–51 Brenner N, Jessop B, Jones M and MacLeod G 2002
Introduction: State space in question in Brenner N, Jessop B, Jones M and MacLeod G eds State/space: a reader Blackwell, Oxford 1–26 Brotton J 1997 Trading territories: mapping the early modern world Reaktion Books, London Bulpitt J 1983 Territory and power in the United Kingdom:
an interpretation Manchester University Press, Manchester Camille M 2000 Signs of the city: place, power, and public fantasy in medieval Paris in Hanawat B A and Kobialka M eds Medieval practices of space University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis 1–36 Castells M 1989 The informational city:
information technology, economic restructuring and the urban-regional process Blackwell, Oxford Castells M 1996 The rise of network society Blackwell, Oxford Castree N 2003 The geopolitics of nature in Agnew J, Mitchell K and Toal G eds A companion to political geography Blackwell, Oxford 423–39 Cohen P C 1999 A calculating people: the spread of numeracy in early America Routledge, New York Cox K R ed 1997 Spaces of
globalisation: reasserting the power of the local Guilford Press, New York Cox K R 2002 Political geography: territory, state and society Blackwell, Oxford Deleuze G and Guattari F 1986 Kafka: toward a minor literature translated by Dana Polan University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis Deleuze G and Guattari F 1988 A thousand plateaus: capitalism and schizophrenia translated by Brian Massumi Athlone, London Deleuze G and Guattari F 1994 What is philosophy? translated by Hugh Tomlinson and Graham Burchill Verso, London Descartes R 1954 The geometry of René Descartes French- Latin-English edition, translated by David Eugene Smith and Marcia L Latham Dover, New York Descartes R 1964ff Oeuvres de Descartes 13 vols Adam C and Tannery P eds Vrin, Paris Dickmann F 1972 Der Wastfälische Friede Aschendorff, Münster 3 Auflage Elden S 2001 The place of geometry:
Heidegger’s mathematical excursus on Aristotle The Heythrop Journal 42
311–28
Elden S 2003 Another sense of Demos: Kleisthenes and the Greek division of the Polis Democratization 10 135–56 Elden S 2004a Understanding Henri
Lefebvre: theory and the possible Continuum, London Elden S 2004b The state of territory under globalisation:
Empire and the politics of reterritorialization in Margaroni M and Yiannopoulou E eds Borne across:
metaphoricity and postmodern politics Rodopi, Amsterdam Escolar M 2002 Exploration, cartography and modernization in Brenner N, Jessop B, Jones M and MacLeod G eds State/space: a reader Blackwell, Oxford 29–52 Euclid
1956 The thirteen books of Euclid’s elements 3 vols 2nd edn with introduction and commentary by Thomas L Heath Dover, New York Giddens A
1985 The nation-state and violence Polity Press, Cambridge Gottman J 1973 The significance of territory University Press of Virginia, Charlottesville Gross L 1948 The peace of Westphalia 1648–1948 The American Journal of International Law 42 20–41 Hall E T 1969 The hidden dimension Doubleday & Co., New York Hardt M and Negri A 2000 Empire Harvard University Press, Cambridge Harley J B 2001 The new nature of maps: essays in the history of cartography Laxton P ed Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore Harvey D
1969 Explanation in geography Basil Blackwell, Oxford Heidegger M 1953 Einführung in die Metaphysik Max Niemeyer, Tübingen Herz J H 1957 Rise and demise of the territorial state World Politics IX 473–93 Johnston R J
1982 Geography and the state: an essay in political geography Macmillan, London Jonssen C, Tagil S and Tornqvist G 2000 Organising European space Sage, London Kelly P F 1999 The geographies and politics of globalisation Progress in Human Geography 23 379–400 Klein J 1992 Greek mathematical thought and the origin of algebra Dover, New York Kratochwil F 1986 Of systems, boundaries and territoriality:
an inquiry into the formation of the state system World Politics XXXIX
27–52 Kremer B M 1989 Der Wastfälische Friede in der Deutung der Aufklärung Mohr, Tübingen Kuehls T 1996 Beyond sovereign territory: the space of ecopolitics University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis Lachterman D R 1989 The ethics of geometry: a genealogy of modernity Routledge, New York Lang H S 1992 Aristotle’s Physics and its medieval varieties State University of New York Press, Albany Lefebvre H 1978 De l’état tome IV:
Les contradictions de l’état moderne la dialectique et/de l’état UGE, Paris Leibniz G 1969 OEuvres de Leibniz 7 vols Foucher de Careil L A ed Olms Verlag, Hildesheim Leibniz G 1983–4 Sämliche Schriften und Briefe Vierte Reihe:
Politischen Schriften 2 vols Akademie-Verlag, Berlin Leibniz G 1988 Political writings 2nd edn Riley P ed Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Linklater A 1998 The transformation of political community:
ethical foundations of the post-Westphalian era Polity Press, Cambridge Linklater A 2003 Measuring America: how the United States was shaped by the greatest land sale in history Plume, New York Livingstone D N 1990 Geography, tradition and the scientific
revolution: an interpretative essay Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, NS 15 359–73 Lull J 1995 Media, communication,
culture: a global approach Polity Press, Cambridge MacLeod G 2001 New regionalism reconsidered: globalisation and the remaking of political economic space International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 25
804–29
Malmberg T 1980 Human territoriality: survey of behavioural territories in man with preliminary analysis and discussion of meaning Mouton Publishers, The Hague Mann M 1985 The autonomous power of the state: its origins, mechanisms and results Archives Européennes de Sociologie XXV 185–213 Mirabelli A R 1929 Le congrès de Westphalie: ses negotiations et ses reultats au point de vue de l’histoire du droit des gens Bibliotheca Visseriana Dissertationum ivs internationale illustrantium VIII Moser J J
1745 Grund-riss de heutigen Staats-Verfassung des Teutschen Reichs 5th edn Cotta, Tübingen Newman D and Paasi A 1998 Fences and neighbours in the postmodern world: boundary narratives in political geography Progress in Human Geography 22 186–207 O’Brien R 1992 Global financial integration:
the end of geography Royal Institute of Financial Affairs, London Ohmae K 1990 The borderless world: power and strategy in the interlinked economy Harper Collins, London Ohmae K 1995 The end of the nation state: the rise of regional economies Harper Collins, London Osiander A 1994 The states system of Europe, 1640–1990:
peacemaking and the conditions of European stability Clarendon Press, Oxford Osiander A 2001 Sovereignty, international relations, and the Westphalian myth International Organization 55 251–
87
Ó Tuathail G 1998 Political geography III: dealing with deterritorialization Progress in Human Geography 22 81–
93
Ó Tuathail G 2000 Borderless worlds? Problematizing discourses of deterritorialization Geopolitics 4 139–54 Paasi A 2003 Territory in Agnew J, Mitchell K and Toal G eds A companion to political geography Blackwell, Oxford
109–22
Pacione M ed 1985 Progress in human geography Croom Helm, London Pagès G
1939 La guerre de trente ans 1618–1648 Payot, Paris Pakenham T 1991 Scramble for Africa 1876–1912 Weidenfeld & Nicolson, London Papastergiadis N 2000 The turbulence of migration: globalisation, deterritorialization and hybridity Polity Press, Cambridge Pattison W D 1970 Beginnings of the American rectangular land survey system 1784–1800 Ohio Historical Society, Columbus Prescott J R V 1968 The geography of state policies Hutchinson University Library, London Prescott J R V 1972 Political geography Methuen, London Riley P ed 1988 Introduction in Leibniz G Political writings 2nd edn Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
1–44
Riley P 1996 Leibniz’ universal jurisprudence: justice as the charity of the wise Harvard University Press, Cambridge Ruggie J 1993 Territoriality and beyond: problematizing modernity in international relations International Organization
47 139–74
Sack R D 1983 Human territoriality: a theory Annals of the Association of American Geographers 73 55–74 Sack R 1986 Human territoriality: its theory and history Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Sahlins P 1989
Boundaries: the making of France and Spain in the Pyrenees University of California Press, Berkeley Scholte J A 2000a
Globalisation: a critical introduction Macmillan, Houndmills Scholte J A 2000b Global civil society in Woods N ed The political economy of globalisation Macmillan, London 173–
201
Scholte J A forthcoming Globalisation: a critical introduction 2nd edn Shapiro M J 1997 Violent cartographies: mapping cultures of war University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis Stone J C 1988 Imperialism, colonialism and cartography Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, NS 13
57–64
Storey D 2001 Territory: the claiming of space Prentice Hall, Harlow Taylor P J 1994 The state as container: territoriality in the modern world-system Progress in Human Geography 18
151–62
Taylor P J 1995 Beyond containers: internationality, interstateness, interterritoriality Progress in Human Geography
19 1–15
Taylor P J 1999 Place, spaces and Macy’s: place-space tensions in the political geography of modernities Progress in Human Geography 23 7–26 Treaty of Tordesillas 7 June 1494 translation at http:// www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/modeur/mod001.htm
Treaty of Westphalia Münster 24 October 1648 in Parry C ed 1969 The consolidated treaty series Dobbs Ferry, New York 231 Volumes, Volume I; translation at http:// www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/westphal.htm
Treaty of Westphalia Osnabrück 24 October 1648 in Instrumentum Pacis Westphalicae/Die Westfälischen Friedensverträge Latin-German edition Herbert Lang, Bern 1975 Virilio P 1975 L’insécurité du territoire Stock, Paris Virilio P 1986 Speed and politics: an essay on dromology translated by Mark Polizzotti Semiotexte, New York Virilio P 1999 Polar inertia translated by Patrick Camiller Sage, London Virilio P and Lotringer S 1983 Pure war translated by Mark Polizzotti Semiotexte, New York Walker R B J 1993 Inside/outside: international relations as political theory Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Weber M 1971 Politik als Beruf in Winckelmann J ed Gesammelte Politische Schriften Mohr, Tübingen 505–60 Weber M 1994 The profession and vocation of politics in Lassman P and Speirs R eds Political writings Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
309–69 Williams C H 2003 Nationalism in a democratic context in Agnew J, Mitchell K and Toal G eds A companion to political geography Blackwell, Oxford 356–77 Wyduckal D 1998 The imperial constitution and the imperial doctrine of public law: facing the institutional challenge of the peace of Westphalia in Bussmann K and Schilling H eds 1648 War and peace in Europe 2 vols Münster/Osnabrück Vol I 77–83 Yeung H W 1998 Capital, state and
space: contesting the borderless world Transactions, Institute of British Geographers
23 291–309
Zumthor P 1993 La mesure du monde: représentation de l’espace au Moyen age Seuil, Paris.