Publication details for Prof. Barbara GraziosiGraziosi, Barbara & Haubold, Johannes (2003). 'Homeric Masculinity: ΗΝΟΡΕΗ and ΑΓΗΝΟΡΙΗ'. Journal of Hellenic Studies 123: 60-76.
- Publication type: Journal papers: academic
- ISSN/ISBN: 0075-4269
- View online: Online version
- Durham research online: DRO record
Author(s) from Durham
This article investigates concepts of masculinity in the Homeric poems by focusing on two words: ἠνορέη and ἀγηνορίη. We argue that whereas ἠνορέη is a positive quality best understood as 'manliness', ἀγηνορίη denotes 'excessive manliness' in a pejorative sense. By comparing the use of these two terms we claim that it is possible to explore what constitutes proper, as opposed to excessive, masculinity in the Homeric poems. Our analysis of ἠνορέη and ἀγηνορίη suggests that some current views of Homeric masculinity need to be reconsidered. Whereas much recent scholarship has emphasized the individualism of 'the Homeric hero', we suggest that individualistic behaviour on the part of men is presented as a serious problem in the Homeric poems. As well as the use of the terms ἠνορέη and ἀγηνορίη, the frequent injunctions to 'be men' found in the poems confirm that solidarity with other men is an important aspect of Homeric masculinity. Our analysis also shows that the language of masculinity is employed very differently in the Iliad and the Odyssey. In the Iliad, excessive manliness is typically displayed by an individual who fails to show solidarity with other men on the battlefield. In the Odyssey, the suitors are standardly designated as 'excessively manly' for coveting another man's wife. In both poems, normative definitions of masculinity seek to regulate proper relationships among men.