Link to Home pageLink to GlossaryLink to TimelineLinks to useful websitesLink to worksheet Print the sources  
Home > The struggle to end slavery > The pro-slavery argument > Source 4 > More information

The pro-slavery argument. Source 4 information

  • The Committee of West India Planters and Merchants was formed in the late eighteenth century to represent the interests of plantation owners and traders who lived in the West Indies and in England (specifically around London). In the first few decades of its existence, much of its time was spent defending slavery and the slave trade.
  • After slavery was abolished, the Committee remained in existence and started to campaign against the removal of beneficial duties on West Indian sugar and encourage immigration of labourers from India, Africa and China to replace slave labour.
  • By the late ninteenth century the Committee had started to represent interests in the West Indies other than sugar and its role continued to expand in the twentieth century.
  • This Memorial is contained in the letters and papers of Charles, 2nd Earl Grey. Grey was Prime Minister from 1830-1834 and received many letters regarding the question of abolition.
  • Charles Grey first entered Parliament in 1786 as MP for Northumberland, aged 22. He was a supporter of the Whigs, led by Charles James Fox, and soon became one of the leaders. In 1806, when his father became the first Earl Grey, Charles became Viscount Howick. In that same year, he was appointed First Lord of the Admiralty in what became known as the Ministry of All Talents. Later that year, following the death of Fox, Grey became Foreign Secretary and leader of the Whigs.
  • In 1807, Grey's father died and he inherited the title. As 2nd Earl Grey, Charles could no longer remain in the Commons and took up his seat in the Lords. He did, however, remain leader of the Whigs who by this time had fallen from power. Grey spent the next 23 years in opposition before being made Prime Minister in 1830.
  • Grey had long been a supporter of reform and during his Ministry he steered through a number of important measures. These included: the Reform Act of 1832 which gave more people the vote; the Factory Act of 1833 which aimed to give more protection to children at work; the reform of the Poor Law; and, of course, the Act that abolished slavery.


  • In this extract, the planters and merchants show their fear that news of the intended Act will cause the slaves to rise up in rebellion. This fear had a real basis. In late 1831/early 1832, there had been a rebellion of over 20,000 slaves in Jamaica. Led by a Baptist lay preacher, called Sam Sharp, the slaves had gone on strike demanding payment for their work. The rebellion was crushed by the military and over 750 slaves were convicted of taking part, most of whom were sentenced to death.


  • The other argument used by the planters in this extract is that compensation must be paid if abolition occured. This argument was based on the belief that Parliament had no right to interfere with a person's property. If slavery was to be abolished then the planters should be compensated for the loss of their property. This argument was ultimately accepted and the planters were given £20 million in compensation. According to a House of Commons research paper, this would be equivalent to £1,280,000,000 today.

Close window

 

Home | Glossary | Timeline | Links | Worksheet | Print